Skip to main content

Per Homes.com ‘It’s a reckoning:’ Home sellers face new pricing reality"

News and Insights
|
Housing Market Click here for the direct Homes.com Article Link.
‘It’s a reckoning:’ Home sellers face new pricing reality

Agents address picky buyers, ambitious pricing in today’s housing market. Inventory and days on market have begun to increase nationwide, prompting agents to reality-check sellers. (Matthew Stott/CoStar)




By Caroline Broderick Moira Ritter
November 11, 202611:11 AM ET10,932 Views
Key takeaways:Real estate agents across the country say sellers are facing a market reckoning, as cautious buyers are no longer willing to pay above asking for a home.
The housing market is splitting into a K-shaped pattern, where homes priced under $300,000 still see strong buyer competition while mid-priced and higher-priced listings sit longer due to fewer qualified buyers.
Agents are urging sellers to price homes realistically as inventory rises and days on market lengthen.


As many buyers retreat from the housing market, sellers are confronting a harsh new reality when it comes to pricing their homes.

"It's a reckoning," Rick Roberts, an agent with HomeSmart Realty South in Metairie, Louisiana, told Homes.com News in an interview. "The multiple offers, pricing high and seeing what flies, it doesn't work anymore. They've got to be realistic."

Real estate professionals across the country echoed that sentiment last weekend at the industry’s largest gathering, NAR NXT, citing affordability and uncertainty as the top challenges plaguing both buyers and sellers in today's market. That comes ahead of what's expected to be another slow winter selling season.

"This is a very, very tough market condition," National Association of Realtors Chief Economist Lawrence Yun said during his annual economic forum at the conference.

The market is on track for its fourth straight year of historically low home sales as elevated mortgage rates and rising home prices amplify affordability challenges for buyers. On top of that, economic and geopolitical pressures have sapped consumer confidence.

"The market has changed drastically," Kaera Mims, an agent with Abbitt Realty Co. in Newport News, Virginia, added. "Sellers are looking in the past, and buyers are looking in the current and future."

Middle-income markets take a hit across the country
The NAR NXT conference was held Nov. 6 through Nov. 8 in New Orleans. The association said 10,000 member agents were in attendance. (Caroline Broderick/Homes.com)



That disparate perspective is breeding discontent among buyers and sellers alike, according to Heather Thompson-McAfee of Coldwell Banker in Bedford, New Hampshire.

“It’s creating buyer frustration, and sellers want to still have more discussion,” McAfee told Homes.com News. “We have a definite boiling point coming.”


The bifurcation is adding fuel to what economists and the NAR call a K-shaped economy — where higher-income households continue to prosper, while low- and middle-income households increasingly struggle with affordability.

In the housing market, that divide is reflected in the types of buyers transacting and the types of homes they're buying.

In Mims' Virginia market, for example, there are "two different markets," she explained. Buyers are facing higher competition for more affordably priced homes, while higher-priced homes are entering a market with fewer eligible buyers.

"Our lower price points, I'd say $300,000 and below, is still a little bit of a sellers' market, especially if the condition is ‘chef's kiss,'" Mims said.

In Metairie, Louisiana, Donna Chandler said that pricing split is playing out in her business.

"My high end is moving; my low end is moving. The middle is sitting," she told Homes.com News in an interview. "The everyday person who's affected by the insurance rates and interest rates, they want to stay put."


In other words, activity has been more resilient among entry-level and high-end buyers. While affordable homes remain scarce and in demand, wealthier buyers have gained financial flexibility that's allowed them to more easily absorb higher costs. In some markets, like New Orleans, this has put upward pressure on median sales prices as higher-end deals persist.

For move-up buyers who fall somewhere in the middle, though, buying a new home often means giving up a lower mortgage rate for a more expensive home financed at today's higher rates. That's been compounded by broader inflation in the economy, creating even greater financial strain.

Agents focus on education and adaptation heading into 2027.

With pickier buyers and higher inventory, homes are sitting on the market for longer, too. Sellers have yet to fully understand this, agents say.

“You have to tell sellers there’s more on the market. You’re going to have more competition. The top dollar might not be there right now,” said Steve Bottom with Realty Group Resources in Elkhart, Indiana.

Nationally, inventory increased in September as sales pulled back, pushing up the median days on market for a home, according to Homes.com housing market data. In general, buyers faced less competition in the month while sellers listed to lackluster demand. Still, agents noted continually having to inform sellers of appropriate pricing to attract activity.

“If you’re not priced right, you’re going to sit on the market,” said Chicago agent Erika Villegas with ReMax in the Village. “You don’t want to be part of that average number of 45 days" that homes are currently sitting for in Chicago, she said.
Agent Kaera Mims from Newport News, Virginia, pictured above, said the lower-end of the market continues to see lots of demand amid lower inventory. (Brian Ford/CoStar)

Agents are also adjusting to a new selling reality, according to Holly Mabery, chief brokerage officer at eXp Realty.

"Going into 2027, our reality is that we’re looking at 3.7 to 3.8 million home sales a year. That’s where we’ve been the last few years, and it’s likely where we’re going to be going forward," she told Homes.com News in an interview. "The market will be what you make of it, but you have to adapt."

Even in a softened market, agents and industry leaders have pointed to the housing shortage, continued desire for homeownership and life changes as tailwinds.

People are only buying and selling if they have to.

Meanwhile, an April 2026 poll by Gallup found 67% of U.S. adults believe it is a bad time to buy a house. With that sentiment, many in the market are forced to move due to major life events, such as divorce, death and job relocation.

“Nobody is selling because they want to sell,” Jami Purser, an agent with Purser Realty in Atlanta, told Homes.com News. “And same thing with buyers.”

Purser is telling some clients to stay put if they can and wait for improved affordability, most specifically with mortgage rates.

In Indiana, Bottom noted fewer buyers in his market than just three months ago. Part of the pullback comes from seasonality, and another from the general view that it is a difficult time to enter the market.

But Bottom is part of a different cohort of agents who believe it’s not ideal to wait to time rates, and that it remains an ideal time for buyers as they gain leverage.

“Don’t let that interest rate stop you. If it does come down, you can refinance later. It’s a great time for a buyer right now, honestly,” he said.

Caroline Broderick is a staff writer for Homes.com News, focusing on Chicago and the Midwest. A Chicagoland native, she has experience as an editor in residential construction, covering design, market trends, business and mental health.Read Full Bio
Moira Ritter

Moira Ritter is an award‑winning real estate journalist for Homes.com News, specializing in the California housing market. She’s passionate about translating complex housing data into stories that resonate with everyday readers, from shifting mortgage rates to the trends reshaping affordability across the country. Her reporting on the aftermath of Hurricane Helene in North Carolina earned honors from the National Association of Real Estate Editors.Read Full Bio
Was this page helpful?
Send your queries to

Homes.com follows strict editorial standards to provide you real estate news you can trust. Read our Editorial Policy.

    Comments

    Most Popular Posts on ATX Real Estate Life Blog

    How much would my real estate lease or sell for in 2026? Contact Licensed Broker Associate Austin Silent Market George Vance McGee for a customized CMA

      George Vance McGee  is a friendly, experienced, and actively licensed  Broker Associate with Austin Silent Market Inc.  A proud  Austin native (yes—true Unicorn status) , George brings over  15 years of hands-on real estate experience  serving the Central Austin and greater Central Texas residential marketplace. George is a long-standing and engaged  Austin Board of Realtors® member , and in 2019 he proudly volunteered and served on  ABOR’s Diversity Council and Committee , reflecting his commitment to community, inclusion, and thoughtful growth in Austin real estate. He is currently the volunteer Democratic Precinct Chair for the St. Elmo, SoCo neighborhood and area. He is also currently volunteers as the University of Texas Men's Lacrosse Club Alumni Reporter.  A graduate of  Stephen F. Austin High School (2000)  and  The University of Texas at Austin (2004) , George earned his Bachelor’s Degree in Liberal Arts while a...

    THE UNICORN LIST for Austin, Texas 2026 Edition via GVM Real Estate Broker:

      🦄 GVM's Austin Texas UNICORN LIST™ George Vance McGee's Favorite Local Professionals, Businesses & Hidden Gems 2026 Austin Edition By George Vance McGee, Austin Native, Real Estate Broker Associate, Austin Silent Market Austin is a rapidly & constantly changing city, but some local businesses, professionals, and community institutions continue to stand out. Over years of working in real estate sales, leasing, lot development and simply enjoying life in Austin, I've developed my personal "UNICORN LIST" of trusted local resources. A "Unicorn" is an ATX resident who was born and raised in Austin, TX. My mother Andrea Roberts McGee (rest in peace) birthed me at Seton Hospital on West 38th Street in November of 1981.  ⚖️ Real Estate Attorneys Claiborne Cowan & Associates Wills Probate Estate Planning Real Estate Legal Matters Jon M. Daves Evictions Landlord & Tenant Law Leasing Disputes Property Rights Shapiro & Dunn Business Law Practi...

    Should you BUY a FLIPPED House? ATX Broker Associate GVM Tips, Insights.

     SHOULD YOU BUY a "FLIPPED" HOUSE?  Have you personally ever considered and wondered if you, yourself should BUY  a "flipped house." In my 15+ years of predominantly residential Central Austin brokerage practice and experience, here are my insights, opinions, suggestions and things to be cognizant of.  #1. Absolutely, for sure get a LICENSED INSPECTION on the flipped house! Not all flippers are the same. Just like in life there is a wide spectrum in regards to quality. Some flippers are flat out awful. They make very lipstick-like improvements, skip the expensive items such as the foundation, and plumbing and try to trick the consumer into paying more for a home, when the consumer shouldn't.  On the Flip Side (this joke was just too obvious) There are also excellent high-quality flippers whom selectively choose which homes they flip, and then they invest carefully and beautifully while genuinely  improving a home! Some of these hi-quality upper tier flippe...