Skip to main content

Per The Austin Monitor, Austin City Planning Commissioners Blast Crestview Single Family Home-Owners for Unequal treatment of Renters


Friday, June 11, 2021 by Jonathan Lee

Planning Commissioners blast unequal treatment of renters

A rezoning case at Tuesday’s Planning Commission meeting sparked a conversation among commissioners over the disparate treatment between renters and single-family homeowners in the rezoning process. 

A 330-unit multifamily project with 33 income restricted units is slated for a long, narrow, 4-acre lot at 7113 Burnet Road that abuts several single-family homes. The developer of the project requests Multifamily Residence-Highest Density (MF-6) zoning. Various types of commercial zoning are currently in place on different parts of the lot. 

The developer has made concessions to neighbors who are against the project. Both parties have agreed to a conditional overlay that provides 20 feet between the proposed building and the adjacent homes. A restrictive covenant limits the building’s height to 75 feet and requires the developer to plant mature trees to screen the building, among other provisions. Overall, the developers’ commitments go above and beyond the code-mandated compatibility standards.   

One clause in the proposed restrictive covenant drew the ire of some commissioners: The units near single-family homes, at the request of neighbors, cannot have full balconies, only six-inch-deep Juliet balconies.

“Please explain to me, why do you need that request?” Commissioner Awais Azhar asked Brad Russell, a neighbor. Russell explained that full balconies would encroach on the neighbors’ privacy. “If they’re on a second story, they can look into all the homes that are surrounding, and the ability to be out there on a balcony for longer periods of time – there’s more impact on our privacy.” Russell said he was also concerned about noisy gatherings on balconies. 

Azhar then brought in the perspective of a future renter: “Do you think that you could potentially inconvenience them from using your yard at late hours?” Russell said he didn’t understand. “I’m not sure how if I’m hanging out in my backyard that would inconvenience someone on a second story or a third story.” Azhar also noted that the maximum height of the apartments adjacent to single-family homes would be 30 feet – about the same as a single family home.

Azhar and Commissioner Joao Paulo Connolly took the opportunity to condemn what they saw as the unequal treatment of renters vs. homeowners.

“I just think it’s worth stating for the record that this is the perfect example of how renters in this city are treated as second-class citizens. So often in our decisions, quality of life matters to homeowners and single-family homes, but quality of life does not matter to renters,” Connolly said. “Let the people in those apartments know that their balconies were robbed by their neighbors in their single-family homes,” he added. 

“It is truly appalling to me that is something that the neighborhood requested,” Azhar said. “It is appalling to me that the applicant agreed to that. And I really hope that that is not a conversation we have again on this dais in this commission or anywhere in the city.”

Eight commissioners, including Azhar and Connolly, voted to recommend the requested MF-6 zoning, and three abstained. City Council was set to vote on the case at yesterday’s meeting, but the case was postponed until July 29 at the request of neighbors. 

The Austin Monitor’s work is made possible by donations from the community. Though our reporting covers donors from time to time, we are careful to keep business and editorial efforts separate while maintaining transparency. A complete list of donors is available here, and our code of ethics is explained here.


Popular posts from this blog

Per Moneywise, Grant Cardone says, "I wouldn't touch the real estate markets of either Austin, Texas or Seattle Washington with a 10 foot pole."

‘I wouldn’t touch Austin, Texas or Seattle, Washington with anybody’s money’ : Grant Cardone says these two major US cities are some of 'the worst markets to be in right now' for real estate investors — here's why Story by Bethan Moorcraft • click here for the exact moneywise article  prolific real estate investor Grant Cardone has singled out two U.S. property markets he wouldn’t touch with a 10-foot pole: Austin and Seattle. Cardone shared this hot take — and many others — in an  interview with Moneywise  after he prompted an AI chatbot to answer the question: “What are the 10 best markets for investing in rental real estate in America?” The AI Smith response started with: “The best markets for investing in real estate in America can vary depending on factors such as population growth, job opportunities, rental demand, affordability and potential rental income.” Up until that point, Cardone — who performed the task live on camera — was pretty happy with the response. But

Sad News. Tim Harrington of Austin, Texas passed away in mid-February 2024 from a heart attack. His Memorial Service is 2/29/2024 2 pm, @ Austin Ridge Bible Church in Westlake.

The Above Photo was taken by Jim Innes during his Podium Eulogy talk for Tim Harrington. To Say the Westlake Austin Ridge Bible Church memorial service was PACKED, would be an understatement. Tim Harrington was a good man, and friend of many. He was relatable, authentic, funny, caring and social.    George Vance..... Just making sure you know that Tim Harrington passed away last weekend. Heart attack.  Tim’s Memorial Service will be: 2/29/24 at 2 PM at Austin Ridge Bible Church at 9300 Bee Cave Rd, Austin, TX 78733 in Westlake. At the Worship Center building. Please spread the word. GVM speaking here, "Tim showed up on my 40th birthday at Pitch N Putt for an afternoon of golf and bullshit. Tim was in good spirits that afternoon after boasting of his mega million dollar commercial fresh sale in SoCo. St. Elmo @ the ol' Hills Cafe.   Tim was a former SOUTHWESTERN door to door salesman and alumnus like me. A fellow bookman. Tim showed up @ my BookPeople booksigning event, for th

The Future of Clarksville & Old West Austin? West 12th and West Lynn Blvd. Recap of Meeting Between the Neighborhood & Zydeco Development.

 Recap of Meeting Between the Neighborhood & Zydeco Development That the CCDC Organized On December 6 th , the principals of Zydeco Development, Meghan Yancy and Wes Gilmer, as well as Miguel  Rivera with Miro-Rivera Architects, talked with neighborhood residents about its plans for redeveloping thebuilding that formerly housed Nau’s, and where Anthony’s is still located, the parking lot between Anthony’s and CafĂ© Medici, the house where the coffee house is located, and the two houses on Eason that back up to the parking lot. Zydeco, a small, local real estate development firm founded by Howard Yancy, closed on all of this real estate  about three months ago. Miguel Rivera who lives on Patterson, is Zydeco’s architect for the project. Meghan lives on 14 th Street. During the meeting, Miguel and Meghan emphasized that they understand how important the properties along West Lynn are to the neighborhood, especially the “Nau’s building,” because they are neighbors. Meghan explained